November 27, 2022

Saving Break

Break Through With Legalicy

In a scarred Hong Kong, “beautiful items are gone” | The Mighty 790 KFGO

By Yik Lam and Jessie Pang

HONG KONG (Reuters) – As documentary filmmaker Kiwi Chow walked by a pedestrian tunnel in Hong Kong on a current day, he noticed a crew of cleaners scraping off glue still left by unlawful adverts and scrubbing the partitions clear with mops.

It reminded him of the day he became an activist through the professional-democracy protests that galvanised this Chinese-dominated city in 2019. Back again then, he had gathered with his young son and some mates to cover a different tunnel wall with Post-it notes scribbled with political messages and drawings.

Strangers joined in.

“I was quite content. It was the 1st time I was an organiser,” he claimed.

The next day, as he walked earlier, cleaners had been eradicating the mosaic of notes, acknowledged in Hong Kong as “Lennon walls” just after the authentic John Lennon Wall in communist-controlled Prague in the 1980s that was lined with graffiti, Beatles lyrics and messages of political grievance.

Urged over the phone by his wife, he collected some of the notes from the floor. “Pick as considerably as you can,” she instructed him. “Bring back again the drawing by your son!”

The cleaners on that day in August 2019 explained to Chow that they essential to apparent the tunnel wall and photograph it as proof of their operate for their bosses. But then they instructed him that he could place the Post-its back again on the other aspect of the tunnel.

To Chow, that was the cleaners’ act of resistance, an working experience that motivated him to use his very own profession for the result in.

“This is the Hong Kong spirit,” he considered, and took his camera out to film the protests. He hopes to complete enhancing the documentary later on this calendar year.

Clearing the Lennon Partitions was the starting of “beautiful things” staying ruined, he stated.

“Of training course, we experience angry when attractive points are absent it is important, and we will need to recall. But the anger can also transfer into perseverance,” reported Chow, now 42. After all, during the protests, the Lennon wall in his tunnel was dismantled a lot of times, but people today rebuilt it.

But now, Lennon walls have disappeared. They’ve been risky to assemble considering that China introduced a sweeping countrywide security law a year ago to crack down on what it deems subversion, secessionism, terrorism and collusion with overseas forces with up to everyday living in jail.

People today who want a democratic long run for the metropolis are regrouping guiding an invisible entrance line that is more challenging to disrupt with tear fuel and rubber bullets, but nevertheless, they say, under assault: the memory of what transpired in 2019.

Democracy activists charge that people in electricity are attempting to choose handle of the narrative, and they worry that long run generations will listen to only the government’s model of activities: that the 2019 protests ended up illegal riots by a minority of men and women who had been manipulated by overseas forces to undermine the increase of China less than the thriving management of the Communist Bash.

Public broadcaster RTHK has eliminated archives made up of reveals covering the protests or that had been critical of the government and investigating people in electrical power, prompting on-line activists to move backup copies on to blockchain platforms.

Authorities have declared sure slogans and tracks unlawful, have eliminated or reframed sensitive subject areas in college curricula and pulled democracy textbooks off the shelves of community libraries. Cinemas, universities and artwork galleries have cancelled screenings or exhibitions of protest-related is effective.

The Hong Kong governing administration lately enacted new guidelines that permit authorities to censor films on the foundation of safeguarding nationwide protection. “The censor ought to be vigilant to the portrayal, depiction or procedure of any act or action which may possibly total to an offence endangering nationwide stability … and any information of a film which is objectively and moderately able of currently being perceived as endorsing, supporting, selling, glorifying, encouraging or inciting these kinds of act or activity,” the suggestions state.

Chinese and area authorities deny freedoms have been curbed and say their steps are important to protect the red line of national protection, restore security and carry prosperity.

Responding to issues from Reuters, a federal government spokesman stated that “no civil culture in the planet could accept these kinds of violence and vandalism” as transpired in what he termed the “riots” of 2019. The govt, he reported, “has no tolerance for illegal functions and strongly decries any attempt to glorify unlawful acts working with the justification of independence and democracy.”

On censorship principles, Hong Kong leader Carrie Lam explained in June that her federal government experienced to strike a equilibrium involving respecting resourceful flexibility and safeguarding national security and that officers “will talk about with the industry to allay their fears and anxiety.”

RTHK, the broadcaster, mentioned its new archive coverage for social media platforms matches its exercise for the formal web site, which retains programmes from the earlier 12 months, and that handful of media organisations would continue to keep total archives on-line permanently.

“We fail to see how our archive policy and arrangements for RTHK programmes on YouTube are in any way related to your story about attempts by some persons in Hong Kong to protect and protect their model of the social occasion in 2019,” it claimed.

China’s Hong Kong and Macau Affairs Place of work, which will come underneath the Point out Council, or cupboard, and the Hong Kong Liaison Workplace, Beijing’s top representative physique in the metropolis, didn’t answer to requests for remark.

It is not only a fight over the narrative: Given that the protests died down previous yr, the city’s really landscape has altered, leaving acquainted sites unfamiliar.

Suspended footpaths that protesters applied to start petrol bombs have been lined with fences and barbed wire. Plastic, h2o-loaded barriers encompass and defend administrative structures, forcing pedestrians to cross to the other side or wander as a result of a slim corridor in concerning the limitations and police in riot gear standing guard.

Litter bins through the metropolis, which protesters utilized as shields, have been replaced with plastic bags hanging from a metallic loop. Paved sidewalks, from which protesters dug up bricks to toss at police, have been repaired with concrete.

“If Hong Kong is a individual, the ground is the skin. It is like they are carrying out a laser surgery,” stated Jade Chung, a 24-year-old freelance journalist whose operate focuses on human legal rights and professional-democracy activists’ struggle for liberty.

Outside of the actual physical changes, she explained that after the govt began to crack down, a lot of points grew to become tricky to say out loud. That has led to solution codes of resistance in opposition to authoritarian rule, she stated.

When Chung asked for the Wi-Fi password at a small Hong Kong restaurant a short while ago, she acquired an answer that was a lot extra than that: 721831101.

July 21, August 31 and October 1 were being three of the most violent days of the unrest in 2019, a password connecting Chung with a earlier she feels authorities are making an attempt to rewrite following regaining control.

“I guess it is the only way we can categorical ourselves now,’” Chung reported.

She desires to unlock a edition of situations that won’t be instructed in record classes and is fading from community discourse.

“We do not want to keep in mind, nonetheless do not dare to forget. Persons do several things on the aspect to safeguard our collective memory,” mentioned Chung, who contributed to “Road to Hong Kong,” a reserve about the protests. “We did not overlook. We may perhaps be ready for a chance to do anything.”

In the yr considering the fact that the stability law was released, minutes ahead of the July 1 anniversary of the former British colony’s return to Chinese rule, China has also overhauled the city’s political technique, demanding that anyone keeping general public office is “patriotic” and faithful to Beijing. Most opposition politicians and democratic activists are either in jail, ensnared by the new law or for other factors, or in exile.

In mid-April, Hong Kong authorities marked “National Stability Instruction Working day,” with college things to do, online games and displays, and a parade by law enforcement and other services performing the Chinese military’s “goose step” march.

In colleges and cultural centres, residents ended up invited to establish nationwide stability “mosaic walls,” a prime-down, organised edition of the 2019 Lennon walls. “Supporting the nationwide stability legislation is not an concern. Help! Aid! Aid! I hope we can be a single with the mainland,” one particular Submit-it on a wall established up at the Wong Cho Bau Secondary School read.

Little ones were specified toy variations of police guns and played with them below the watchful eye of cops in riot gear, together with inside of a duplicate of a subway prepare carriage. To lots of in Hong Kong, these pictures have been a surreal shadow participate in of the broadly televised scenes of police officers charging onto a practice on August 31, 2019, pepper-spraying and hitting cowing kids with batons.


The fight with the governing administration in the arena of symbols, phrases and lifestyle is a sequel to the far more chaotic battles of 2019, when petrol bombs ended up thrown almost on a daily foundation for months on close in just one of the world’s most peaceful metropolitan areas, activists say.

This, far too, is a battle that authorities are not shying absent from.

In early Might, as Herbert Chow was purchasing meal, police vans turned up at his new Chickeeduck shop in the Tsuen Wan district. At initially, Chow imagined authorities ended up there to implement a COVID 19-related lockdown on a close by constructing.

But officers putting on “national stability department” vests started cordoning the space around his shop, drawing crowds of curious onlookers. They entered the store, confirmed him a look for warrant and started searching through the merchandise for sale.

“It’s like they have been raiding a bar to obtain medicines,” Chow recalled, standing in close proximity to a two-meter-tall bust of a protester sporting a helmet, goggles and gas mask and holding a yellow rubber duck previously mentioned his head as if he were being about to toss a Molotov cocktail.

Chow, 57, was putting on a long-sleeved shirt with “Liberate Sausages, Greens of our time” and “Five meatballs, no sauce left” imprinted on it – puns that echo slogans of the protests these types of as “Liberate Hong Kong, Revolution of our time” and “Five requires, not just one much less.” He stated he believed all his ducks were being in a row, legally talking.

Officials have reported the “Liberate Hong Kong” slogan is subversive and illegal, a claim that will be examined in coming months in a court docket scenario versus a motorcycle driver arrested less than the new legislation.

Chow’s store also carries “Be water” beers. The merchandise identify alludes to a protest tactic of taking part in cat and mouse with the law enforcement to drain their sources, impressed by a quote from Hong Kong martial arts legend Bruce Lee, urging fighters to consistently adapt to the enemy.

Chow’s food puns didn’t set off an arrest or any sanction, but the raid was more than enough to frighten two of his workforce, who quit afterward.

“I was incredibly offended – the scale of 1 to 10, the angry degree was 9,” he explained. “The remaining one was worry that they fearful my colleagues and created them give up, which they did do well at.”

Police have reported officers entered the store with a court warrant after receiving a grievance that the store was suspected of violating the nationwide protection law.

Chow claimed he wants his store to become a place of hope.

“We want to explain to men and women that we even now have no cost space,” he said. “It’s since we see that they may well alter historical past.”

Chow, the filmmaker, mentioned his young children are literal reminders of Hong Kong’s record: His son was born in 2014, the yr when protesters of the “Umbrella movement” occupied the most important arteries of the economic district for 79 times his daughter was born in 2019.

“The regime desires us to overlook. I hope to use my camera to bear in mind,” he said. “We are resisting in our reminiscences. We are resisting forgetfulness.”

(Reporting by Lam Yik and Jessie Pang enhancing by Marius Zaharia and Kari Howard)